top of page
Search

Tracy Should Examine Its Own Glass House before Throwing Stones

George Tanguy
Oct 27
4 min read

People who live in glass houses should not throw stones. The City of Tracy should consider that before demanding accountability from Cedar Lane Manufactured Home Park while leaving its own acknowledged storm shelter problem unresolved.


Storm safety is serious. So are decisions that threaten people’s ability to remain in their homes. Residents deserve clear answers, consistent leadership and a workable solution.


The Lyon County 2024 Hazard Mitigation Plan identifies two vulnerabilities in Tracy: a mobile home park without a storm shelter and Swift Lake Park & Campground without one. The city’s own planning record recognizes that people at both locations face exposure to dangerous weather.


Jeff Carpenter stated in the 2024 Lyon County Mitigation Plan "We have 1 mobile home park within the city that does not have a storm shelter and residents are vulnerable to high wind and tornado events. Our municipal campground is active during summer and fall months with RVs and campers and does not have a storm

shelter."



That raises an obvious question: What has Tracy done to correct the danger on its own property?


Manufactured home parks and campgrounds may operate under different legal requirements. That does not excuse city leadership from addressing a safety problem it has already acknowledged. A tornado does not check who owns the

property before destroying it.


Jason Kloss " Regarding an RV park or transitioning it to an RV park, that would require a license and that it would be under the same rules as an RV park"

Link to Video of Jason Kloss from Southwest Human health Services below



Southwest Health and Human Services revoked Cedar Lane’s operating license over failure to comply with an order requiring a city-approved storm shelter or evacuation plan. The park owner must answer for those obligations but so should the Tracy’s Campground. City officials must also answer for their decisions about shelter access and proposed alternatives.


My understanding is that the Veterans Memorial Center previously served as the park’s shelter location before that arrangement was withdrawn. I also understand that a proposed church alternative was rejected and that discussions involving grant assistance for an on-site shelter ended without an agreement.


If that understanding is accurate, the public deserves specific answers. Why was the previous shelter arrangement withdrawn? Why was the church rejected? What conditions would have made either option acceptable? What about the over 40 homes spread throughout Tracy that don’t have basements or concrete fortified inner shelter walls like the two recently built homes on Front St?


The need reaches beyond Cedar Lane. Residents throughout Tracy live in homes without basements or suitable storm protection. They deserve a clearly communicated plan identifying where they can go, when buildings will open and who is responsible for opening them.


Those questions should be answered with records and clear explanations. Simply repeating that the park needs an approved plan does not explain why proposed solutions failed.


With recent discussions about expanding Swift Lake Park’s campground through additional sites, electrical hookups and water service, the city must explain where storm protection fits into those priorities.


During the council’s discussions about expansion, a storm shelter was never addressed. When a shelter does become a topic for the campground consideration, residents deserve a schedule, a funding plan and an explanation of what campers should do until it is available.


Tracy cannot credibly demand urgency from others while accepting indefinite delay on its own property. Tracy’s Swift Lake Campground should also be treated to the same standards and its operation closed until a shelter is constructed.


I believe the immediate next step is to deescalate and should be to reconsider the Veterans Memorial Center and evaluate the Tracy Fire Hall as potential shelter locations.


During my service with the Tracy Volunteer Fire Department, I remember opened doors the fire hall to residents during major storms. I remember the relief on their faces when they came through those doors. That was public service with a direct, meaningful purpose: helping people reach safety.


If that practice has changed, explain why. If either building is unsuitable, identify the deficiencies. If improvements or formal agreements are needed, put those requirements on the table.


Text alerts can help communicate that plan. With the advanced warning gives the city ample time to make those shelter sites open for use.


The City Council, Southwest Health and Human Services, park ownership and emergency management need to resolve this issue publicly and promptly. Publish the requirements. Explain the rejected alternatives. Establish practical shelter arrangements wherever facilities can safely serve that purpose.


Allowing this dispute to continue without a workable solution leaves residents carrying the consequences of everyone else’s failure to reach an agreement.


Public safety demands more than enforcement against a private property owner. It demands that government confront its own shortcomings with the same urgency it expects from others.


Before Tracy throws another stone, it should take a hard look at its own glass house.


Please Sign up and Subscribe to our Blogs for continued content. The area to access that is on the home page at the top and the bottom. Share our content on social media and show support by sharing wit friends & family in the Tracy Community.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page